Myth 3: “No Responses Means It’s Not Working” — The Hidden Value of Silent Engagement

PLANNED GIVING MYTHS & REALITIES

By: Adrienne Wright

In my role as PGM’s client engagement & analytics specialist, I meet with our clients regularly to review their dashboard and track which of their prospects are actively engaging with our planned giving materials. In this blog series, I share common misconceptions I hear repeatedly from our clients—and the realities that allow successful PG officers to shine.

 

Woman with blonde hair and glasses reading papers at a desk with a laptop and coffee mug.

Myth 3: “No Responses Means It’s Not Working” — The Hidden Value of Silent Engagement

When prospects don’t reply, it’s tempting to think your marketing isn’t working. In reality, many planned giving decisions unfold quietly.
  1. Planned Giving Is a Long Decision Process
    Legacy gifts are deeply personal. They often involve family conversations, reflection on values, and coordination with attorneys or financial advisors. Silence frequently signals consideration and planning—not disinterest.
  2. Consistency Builds Confidence
    Every donor profile and educational message reinforces credibility, helping donors feel comfortable naming you in their plans. When they see stories of their peers making planned gifts, they get the signal that “people like me make gifts like these.”
  3. Visibility Matters—Even When Donors Are Quiet
    The donors who seem quiet today may surprise you tomorrow with a call that starts, “I’ve been thinking about this for a while…”. In other cases, donors take action without ever notifying you—adding your organization to their plans and leaving you to learn about it later through their estate.

During a recent dashboard review with a client, I learned they had received a significant estate gift from a donor who never disclosed their intent. Looking back at the engagement history told a clear story: the donor regularly opened planned giving emails, visited the planned giving website multiple times, and remained on the direct mail list for years.

The interest was there—it just wasn’t vocal.

Let’s turn quiet engagement into lasting connections.

Contact us to learn how to interpret engagement beyond responses.

Stay Informed!

Did you find this information interesting? We send content like this every week! Fill out the below form to receive the latest in Planned Giving news, training, and general wisdom right to your inbox.

More Resources

Templates & Downloads

PSAs (Public Service Announcements)

Be notified of our next PSA

Strategy & Best Practices

Recent Blog Posts

70 ½ vs. 73?

IRA Gifting Ages Explained: 70 ½ vs. 73 Tech Tuesday Other donors like me, make gifts like this. We’ve been hearing some confusion from a lot of clients around the age split of 70 ½ vs. 73 for gifting from an IRA. Which is the correct age? What are the rules around...

read more

Wisdom Wednesday – Are you 85?

Understanding Our Most Senior Donors: A Unique Perspective Wisdom Wednesday Are you 85? I didn’t think so… Listen with intent; every donor has a story. We’ve talked about the mindset of our most senior donors in the past. And we’ll most likely talk about it forever....

read more

Tech Tuesday – IRS Discount Rate

Understanding the IRS Discount Rate for Charitable Gift Annuities Tech Tuesday With the signing of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 and the provision referred to as Secure 2.0, there is newfound interest around Charitable Gift Annuities* (CGAs). Because of...

read more

Invitational Marketing Works Better

Marketing is meant to inspire donors and invite them to make an impact. See how invitational messages help you discover untapped resources so you can reach a new level with your planned giving.

Schedule a Demo