Article · Bequest giving

Gifts in Wills

How to Discover, Document, and Steward Bequest Intentions

Some of an organization’s most consequential future gifts may come from donors whose annual contributions rarely attract attention.

A longtime supporter who gives $100 or $250 at a time can remain almost invisible in fundraising reports yet still leave an estate gift that transforms the organization.

Bequest fundraising begins with relationships, not complicated financial conversations. For fundraisers balancing planned giving with other responsibilities, the work centers on three priorities: discover gifts in wills, document donors’ intentions, and maintain the relationships that help those intentions endure.

1

Discover gifts in wills

2

Document donors’ intentions

3

Maintain the relationships that help those intentions endure

Two women smiling together while looking at a laptop

Meet Eleanor

1 · Discover

Look Beyond Gift Size to Recognize Commitment

Consider Eleanor, an example of a longtime donor. A career teacher and graduate of a small liberal arts college, she has supported her alma mater for decades, generally giving no more than $250 at a time. Her giving is loyal, though not perfectly consistent.

In an annual fundraising report, Eleanor might look unremarkable. Through her will, however, she could become one of the institution’s most significant benefactors.

Her motivation is deeply personal. She values how the college shaped her life. Not simply by preparing her to teach, but by helping her become a fuller person. Her gift would extend that opportunity to others.

Eleanor’s story illustrates why gift size alone is an incomplete measure of a donor’s connection. When identifying people for conversations about gifts in wills, look for:

✓

A long history of support, even when individual gifts are modest.

✓

A meaningful personal experience or connection with the organization.

✓

Continued interest in its mission.

✓

A desire to preserve opportunities or services for future generations.

A practical starting point

1

Sort the donor database by first gift date rather than gift amount

2

Review longtime supporters who have given within the past three years

3

Identify 20 for closer attention

4

Begin with one conversation

Treat this as a starting list, not an exclusion rule. Supporters whose current giving has stopped may still feel a strong connection to the organization.

Use Language Donors Understand

Fundraising professionals routinely use terms such as “bequest” and “planned gift.” Donors may think about the same decision more simply: leaving a gift in their will. Use that language in conversations, correspondence, and donor-facing materials.

Fundraisers often say

“Bequest” · “Planned gift”

↓

Donors think

“Leaving a gift in their will”

A straightforward opening might be:

“Thank you for your longtime support. Would you consider including a gift to our organization in your will?”

To connect the question more closely to the donor’s experience, try:

“I know how important the hospital has been to you and your family. Is including a gift in your will something you might consider?”

The purpose is to open a conversation, not deliver a technical presentation. Keep the question brief, then give the donor room to respond.

When a Donor Says Yes, Start with ‘Thank You’

A donor may already have included the organization in their will without telling anyone on staff. In that situation, the decision has been made. The fundraiser’s immediate task is to acknowledge the generosity and understand its meaning.

Begin with a sincere thank-you. Then, if the donor is comfortable continuing, ask an open-ended question:

“What inspired you to make that gift?”
“What has this organization meant to you?”
“What would you most like your gift to accomplish?”
Smiling older man with a white beard giving a thumbs up in a park

Listen for the personal connection behind the decision. A donor may want others to receive an education, benefit from medical care, experience the arts, or find support during a difficult time.

Record that motivation in the donor’s own words.

Staff summary

“interested in supporting education”

In the donor’s own words

“The college helped me become the person I am”

“The college helped me become the person I am” communicates something different (and more useful) than a staff summary such as “interested in supporting education.”

Those words can guide future conversations and help colleagues understand what matters most to the donor.

Leave Room for Plans to Evolve

Do not assume an older donor’s estate plans are permanently settled. Likewise, do not interpret a decline in annual giving as proof that the donor’s commitment has ended.

Keep the focus on the individual relationship:

1Is the donor still interested in the mission?

2Do they welcome contact?

3What do they want the organization to understand about their priorities?

If the donor says no to a conversation about a gift in their will, respect the answer. A gracious response might be:

“

“Thank you for letting me know. If you ever want information about how that works, I would be happy to help.”

Continuing the relationship should not become repeated pressure. The goal is to remain attentive and available while allowing the donor to make their own decisions.

2 · Document

Document the Intention Without Creating Obstacles

Once a donor shares an intention, create a clear record of what they have told you. Documentation should support the relationship, not turn an expression of generosity into a burdensome administrative process. Keep the initial form or conversation simple. More detailed information can be gathered later, as the donor is willing to share it.

Information worth capturing:

01

Stated intention and date shared

Establishes what the donor communicated and when.

02

Gift arrangement, if known

Clarifies whether the donor described a gift in a will or another arrangement.

03

Estimated amount or percentage

If disclosed, provides context for internal planning.

04

Supporting documentation

Distinguishes documented information from verbal statements.

05

Intended gift purpose

Records how the donor wants the gift to help.

06

Motivation in their own words

Guides meaningful stewardship.

07

Recognition & communication preferences

Helps staff respect the donor’s wishes.

08

Next steps & responsible staff

Creates continuity and accountability.

“I know I took care of you”

Some donors may say, “I know I took care of you,” without remembering whether they used a will or a beneficiary designation. Acknowledge the intention, record what is known, and leave room to clarify details later. Do not describe an uncertain arrangement as a confirmed gift in a will.

Helpful follow-up

Another useful follow-up is to offer the organization’s correct legal name and tax identification number for the donor to share with their attorney.

Make the Pipeline Useful Without Overstating Certainty

Planned giving work happens today, while the resulting funds may arrive much later. A clear internal tracking system can make that work visible without suggesting that every intention will produce a predictable amount on a predictable date.

Three older adults smiling around a laptop at an outdoor table

A simple spreadsheet or database report can distinguish among:

Documented intentions

supported by information the donor has provided.

Verbal intentions

with substantive details.

Informal indications

that need further clarification.

Realized gifts

the organization has received.

If estimated values are available, keep them separate from any confidence-weighted planning figures. Make the assumptions explicit rather than presenting estimates as assured proceeds.

Broad time horizons may help explain the long-term nature of the pipeline, but they should not be treated as precise predictions. Changing plans, estate values, and the time needed to administer an estate all complicate forecasting.

The objective is to show the scope and development of the program, not to promise next year’s revenue.

3 · Maintain

Treat Stewardship as an Ongoing Responsibility

Discovering and documenting an intention are milestones, not the finish line. The donor’s relationship with the organization should continue after the paperwork is filed. A useful stewardship cycle is:

1

Discover the intention

2

Thank the donor and understand the motivation

3

Document what the donor chooses to share

4

Maintain meaningful contact

5

Update the record as circumstances change

↺ Then the cycle continues.

Meaningful Stewardship Can Include

Meaningful stewardship does not always require an elaborate program. It can include:

  • ✓A personal call or visit.
  • ✓An update connected to the donor’s interests.
  • ✓A conversation about the people or programs their gift could support.
  • ✓An invitation suited to their preferences.
  • ✓A thoughtful check-in that is not tied to another request.

The central question

The central question is not simply, “Have we contacted this donor?” It is,

“Does this donor continue to feel known, appreciated, and connected?”

Help Donors Learn from Other Donors

Donor stories can make gifts in wills feel personal and understandable. Rather than leading with technical terminology, show why someone chose to give and what they hope their generosity will accomplish.

Useful story prompts include:

“What first connected you to this organization?”
“Why did you decide to include a gift in your will?”
“What do you hope will be possible because of your gift?”

Peer conversations can provide another opening, particularly where donors share a connection such as a school, class year, or reunion. A supporter explaining “This is something I chose to do” offers a different perspective from an institutional appeal.

Connect Today’s Priorities with Tomorrow’s Needs

Campaign conversations can also create opportunities to discuss future support.

For example, a donor helping fund a new building might also be interested in including a gift in their will for an endowed fund intended to support its long-term maintenance.

Keep the purposes distinct:

Today

Current gifts address immediate campaign or construction needs.

Tomorrow

Future estate gifts can support longer-term priorities.

This allows the conversation to encompass both creating something today and sustaining its value for future generations.

Begin With One Conversation

A bequest program does not have to begin with a complex campaign. Start with a manageable sequence:

1

Identify one longtime supporter

2

Reach out through a channel that suits their preferences

3

Thank them for their commitment

4

Ask what the organization has meant to them

5

When appropriate, ask whether they have considered a gift in their will

6

Record the conversation and follow through

Practical takeaway

Clear questions, careful records, and consistent personal attention create a practical foundation for this work. The opportunity lies in recognizing that a donor’s commitment may be far greater than their annual giving suggests.

Ready to Build a Planned Giving Program That Lasts?

If you want to strengthen donor relationships, inspire lasting commitments, and grow a program rooted in trust, we’re here to help. Contact us today to schedule a demo.